• Logo
  • Services
    • Product Design & Build
    • Difficult-to-Outsource Manufacturing
    • Factory Equipment Design & Build
  • Markets
    • Semiconductor and Display Capital Equipment
    • Medical Device
    • Solar and Energy Storage
    • Data Storage
    • Emerging Technologies
  • Applications Expertise
    • Laser Process Development
    • Materials Handling
    • Process Technology Integration
    • Control Systems and Software
    • Flexible Manufacturing
    • Lyo Bead Handling
  • Case Studies
    • Medical Device Manufacturing with Lasers
    • Wafer Flipper Module for Manufacturing Processes
    • Wafer Heat and Cool Stations
    • Semiconductor Platform for Metrology and Inspection
    • Phased Automation Strategy for Emerging Technology
    • Rapid Production Ramp in Solar Cell Processing
    • Expertise in Medical Technology Manufacturing
    • Enabling Volume Manufacturing for Hard Disk Drive Media
    • Optimizing Production Line for Assembly and Test
    • Product Upgrades for Film Frame Handling
    • Automated Liquid Handling
    • Medical Diagnostic Automation
  • Blog
  • About Us
    • Our Team
    • Careers
    • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us

Owens Design

Engineering, Technical Manufacturing and Program Management

Engineering team meeting

Solving the Manufacturing Resource Dilemma with Collaborative Development

April 13, 2023

When speaking with engineering managers, the complaint is always the same: “There’s no way we can get all of our work done with the resources I have!”

The reasons vary: hiring freezes, resources tied up supporting existing products, resolving problems with the last new product, and, simply, too many projects. The two constants: customers have endless requests and the company needs new products to grow.

This blog discusses three traditional methods of adding engineering and manufacturing resources: one where you assume all risk, one where you assume most of the risk, and one where your partner shares the risk with you, which has successfully been used at many innovative manufacturers.

Contracting

Contracting is essentially the same as hiring, except that there is no promise of permanent employment. You provide the tools, training, supervision, and take responsibility for the work output. If the contractor does it wrong, you have to find a new contractor or pay him to do it again.

With a contractor, you agree to a number of hours a week and pay them for it whether you keep them busy or not. Contracting tends to work well for longer term, full-time assignments where you can hire the talent. It can also be a great way to try someone out before you hire them permanently.

Consulting

In contrast, consultants provide their own tools, perform most of their work offsite, do not require close supervision, and usually take responsibility for their work. If they do it wrong, they will usually fix it on their own time. Most consulting is done on an hourly basis, so you pay only for the time they are working on your project.

While the consultant takes more responsibility than the contractor, you still bear most of the risk. Conflicting motivations – such as minimizing scope creep – can be a huge problem for you but is often an acceptable outcome for the consultant as it results in more billable hours.

Regardless, engaging consultants is a great way to access talented people in specialized technical areas for occasional needs. Any development group should have a set of core consultants identified for your staff to draw upon when the need arises.

Collaborative Development

An emerging model is collaborative development, which is fundamentally different from contracting and consulting because the risk is shared much more equally between the individuals and companies involved.

Also referred to as open innovation, collaborative development recognizes that not all smart people work inside your company. When Proctor & Gamble studied sources of innovation in their company as profiled in the Harvard Business Review Article, How P&G Tripled Its Innovation Success Rate, they discovered that there were 200 equally talented scientists or engineers working elsewhere in the world for every one P&G employee. This suggests there are over 1.5 million people P&G could potentially draw upon for new products, manufacturing processes, and materials to reach even higher levels of innovation.

In contrast to consulting and contracting, collaborative development requires a strategic approach and long-term perspective. To be effective, collaborative development should be addressed from a product or company roadmap perspective. Which areas do you want your development team to focus on and which could be done with a partner? Most companies at this point have identified their core competencies, so the question is: what additional technologies, know-how, and skill sets are needed for your product line to be successful? This usually provides a starting point when looking for partners.

Speed Dating Doesn’t Work

Finding a suitable collaborative development partner is challenging. You need to find a company that match both technical and business needs. While you may start the search with one set of criteria, it’s likely that your criteria will evolve as you better understand your potential partner’s capabilities. This process should not be rushed, or a poor decision will likely be made.

Once a collaborative partner is found, it’s essential to have senior management support and involvement to further the relationship. There are many partnership and business issues, such as intellectual property protection and supply agreements, which must be agreed upon. Without the support of senior management, these issues may derail the process.

Finally, a collaborative development relationship is like any long-term relationship because it will take effort and attention to bear fruit. Achieving and maintaining business alignment is a continuous process. Regular discussions of the product roadmap, market conditions, and business goals are necessary. Senior management participation is also extremely important to keep the relationship aligned with overall company goals.

Your Collaborative Development Partner for Design & Manufacturing

Collaborative development requires commitment and the willingness to adjust your perspective on traditional design resources. Properly executed, this emerging method of partnering can expand your resources and minimize development risk.

If you’d like to expand your design, engineering and manufacturing resources while minimizing your development risk, speak with the Owens Design team. For the past 40 years, OEMs and manufacturers seeking factory automation have relied on Owens Design as an extension of their engineering and manufacturing teams to deliver innovative solutions in record time.

Contact us to learn more about custom automation solutions

Filed Under: Blog Posts Tagged With: consulting, contracting, design & manufacturing, engineering and manufacturing resources, manufacturing collaborative development

Owens Design Logo

Owens Design

47427 Fremont Blvd.
Fremont, CA 94538

Main: (510) 659-1800
Sales: (510) 770-8479
Fax: (510) 659-1896
sales@od2025.brightbirdcreative.com

Popular Links

  • Semiconductor Automation
  • Metrology & Inspection Automation
  • Battery & Energy Storage Automation
  • Medical Device Automation
  • Turnkey vs. Contract Manufacturing
  • Our Team
  • Careers
  • Contact Us
Made in California Badge
Owens Design made in America badge
ISO-9001-Mark
ISO-13485-Mark

Copyright © 2026 | Privacy Policy | Terms & Conditions | Cookie Policy | Consent Preferences

We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. By clicking “Accept”, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies.
Do not sell my personal information.
SettingsAccept
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are as essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
SAVE & ACCEPT